Food & Drink

Independent Italian restaurants in Appleton, WI

4 independent, locally-owned Italian restaurants are listed in Appleton, Wisconsin on CheckThisBiz. National chains and franchises are not included. Ranked by how much we could independently verify (listing sources, phone, website and owner verification), the top Italian restaurants are Johnathan's Italian Bistro, Carmella's and Victoria's.

How we rank: email-verified customer reviews on CheckThisBiz first, then independent checks (listing sources, phone, website and domain, owner verification). Paid placement never changes this ranking. Our methods · Sources · Updated November 19, 2026

View on map

4 Italian restaurants in Appleton · Clear

Own one of these? Be the first Italian restaurant people see in Appleton.Get the top spot →

Own one? Run a free health check on your business.

Johnathan's Italian Bistro

Italian Restaurant

1910 N Casaloma Dr, Appleton, WI

Good signals

Carmella's

Italian Restaurant

716 N Casaloma Dr, Appleton, WI

Good signals

Victoria's

Italian Restaurant

3025 W College Ave, Appleton, WI

Good signals

Victoria's Italian Cuisine

Italian Restaurant

503 W College Ave, Appleton, WI

Good signals

Want your business at the top of this page?

Be the first of the Italian restaurants in Appleton, WI that customers see. Get the top spot · or claim your listing to get the verified badge.