La Cecilia
Italian Restaurant655 Montauk Hwy, Brookhaven, NY
Food & Drink
Independent Italian restaurants in Brookhaven, NY
11 independent, locally-owned Italian restaurants are listed in Brookhaven, New York on CheckThisBiz. National chains and franchises are not included. Ranked by how much we could independently verify (listing sources, phone, website and owner verification), the top Italian restaurants are La Cecilia, CIBO and O Sole Mio.
How we rank: email-verified customer reviews on CheckThisBiz first, then independent checks (listing sources, phone, website and domain, owner verification). Paid placement never changes this ranking. Our methods · Sources · Updated September 25, 2026
View on map11 Italian restaurants in Brookhaven · Clear
Own one of these? Be the first Italian restaurant people see in Brookhaven.Get the top spot →Own one? Run a free health check on your business, or see what funding fits this kind of business.
CIBO
Italian Restaurant406 Sunrise Hwy, Brookhaven, NY
O Sole Mio
Italian Restaurant2194 Nesconset Hwy, Brookhaven, NY
Vespa Italian Kitchen & Cocktails
Italian Restaurant3 Hawkins Ave, Brookhaven, NY
Setauket Pastaria
Italian Restaurant4082 Nesconset Hwy, Brookhaven, NY
Elaine's Restaurant and Bar
Italian Restaurant316 Main St, Brookhaven, NY
Vincenzo's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Italian Restaurant343 Route 25A, Brookhaven, NY
Mama Bella's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Italian Restaurant1600 Medford Ave, Brookhaven, NY
Cafe Gia
Italian Restaurant700 Patchogue Yaphank Rd, Brookhaven, NY
Rocco's Pizzeria and Ristorante
Italian Restaurant5507 Nesconset Hwy, Brookhaven, NY
Lombardi's
Italian Restaurant175 Middle Country Rd, Brookhaven, NY
Want your business at the top of this page?
Be the first of the Italian restaurants in Brookhaven, NY that customers see. Get the top spot · or claim your listing to get the verified badge.
For business owners
Need funding for your business in Brookhaven, NY?
Working capital, a line of credit, equipment or an advance refinanced into one payment. What it takes to qualify, what it costs, and what an underwriter actually looks at — from The Company Chronicle.