Food & Drink

Independent pizza restaurants in St Augustine, FL

19 independent, locally-owned pizza restaurants are listed in St Augustine, Florida on CheckThisBiz. National chains and franchises are not included. Ranked by how much we could independently verify (listing sources, phone, website and owner verification), the top pizza restaurants are Your Pie Palencia, Antonio's Pizza and Grill and Bucks Pizza.

How we rank: email-verified customer reviews on CheckThisBiz first, then independent checks (listing sources, phone, website and domain, owner verification). Paid placement never changes this ranking. Our methods · Sources · Updated November 17, 2026

View on map

19 pizza restaurants in St Augustine · Clear

Own one of these? Be the first pizza restaurant people see in St Augustine.Get the top spot →

Own one? Run a free health check on your business.

Your Pie Palencia

Pizza Restaurant

389 Paseo Reyes Dr Ste 205, St Augustine, FL

Strong signals

Antonio's Pizza and Grill

Pizza Restaurant

9155 County Road 13 N, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

Bucks Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

2800 N 6th St, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

Pirate Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

425 W Town Pl, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

Slice Palencia

Pizza Restaurant

163 Palencia Village Dr, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

New York Pizza Company

Pizza Restaurant

163 Palencia Village Dr, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

Hillary's Chicago Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

1974 US-1 S, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

Carmelo's Pizzeria

Pizza Restaurant

146 King St, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

St. Augie's Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

113 King St, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

Puccini's Pizzeria

Pizza Restaurant

85 Ava Way, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

Thunder J's Pizzeria

Pizza Restaurant

3915 A1A S, St. Augustine, FL

Good signals

Antonio's NY Style Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

590 A1a Beach Blvd, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

Romano's On The Beach

Pizza Restaurant

4255 A1A S, 7 & 8, St. Augustine, FL

Good signals

Al's Pizza - St. Augustine

Pizza Restaurant

1 St George St, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

Real Peel Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

213 W King St, St Augustine, FL

Good signals

Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine - Murabella

Pizza Restaurant

5330 FL-16, St. Augustine, FL

Good signals

Rufino's Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

2700 FL-16, St. Augustine, FL

Good signals

Cino's Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

276 San Marco Ave, 276 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine, FL

Some signals

Lava Dome Pizza

Pizza Restaurant

504 St Croix St, St Augustine, FL

Some signals

Want your business at the top of this page?

Be the first of the pizza restaurants in St Augustine, FL that customers see. Get the top spot · or claim your listing to get the verified badge.